Seasons 1–4 were hosted by Wally Bruner and announced by Johnny Olson. Seasons 5–7 were hosted by Larry Blyden and announced by Chet Gould.
Season 1 (1968–1969)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| #001 (#0011-#0015) | July 09, 1968 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | #1 Joel Grey, #2 Joan Rivers, #3 Gordon MacRae, #4 Allan Sherman, #5 Mel Torme |
| #002 (#0021-#0025) | July 16, 1968 | Darryl Hickman, Phyllis Newman, Gawn Granger, Arlene Francis | #1 Bennett Cerf, #2 Dr. Joyce Brothers, #3 Godfrey Cambridge |
| 3 | 07/23/68 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Alan Alda, AF | Morey Amsterdam, Henry Morgan, Jayne Morgan, Jackie Vernon, John Forsythe |
| #004 (#0041-#0045) | July 30, 1968 | Gene Rayburn, Patti Deutsch, Alan Alda, Arlene Francis | Cliff Robertson, #5 Jack E. Leonard |
| 5 | 08/06/68 | Peter Gabel | Johnny Olson |
| 6 | 08/13/68 | SS, Sue Oakland, Danny Goldman, AF | Peter Finch, Ted Mack, Betsy Palmer, Nipsey Russell |
| #007 (#0071-#0075) | August 20, 1968 | Nipsey Russell, Joanna Barnes, Bert Convy (SS?), Arlene Francis | Fred Clark, Cornel Wilde, Dina Merrill, (Willie Mays) |
| 8 | 08/27/68 | Susan Bracken | Jacqueline Susann, David Susskind |
| 9 | 09/07/68 | Bert Convy, Joanna Simon | Larry Blyden, Pamela Mason, Robert Vaughn, David Wayne |
| 10 | 09/14/68 | Rex Reed | Peter Duchin |
| 11 | 09/21/68 | Morey Amsterdam | Robert Alda, Angie Dickinson, Sheila Graham |
| 12 | 09/26/68 | Karen Machon | Lionel Hampton |
| 13 | 10/01/68 | SS, Pia Lindstrom, Gawn Granger, AF | Otto Preminger, Trevor Howard, Sam Levenson |
| 14 | 10/05/68 | ... | Joe Garagiola |
| 15 | 10/08/68 | ... | Edward Albee, Gig Young |
| 16 | 10/15/68 | Joanne Carson | Ed Ames, Henny Youngman |
| 17 | 10/22/68 | ... | Paula Prentiss, Richard Benjamin, Dick Cavett, Richard Crenna |
| 18 | 10/29/68 | Earl Wilson Jr. | Frank Gifford, Emmett Kelly, Phyllis Newman |
| #019 (#0181-#0185) | November 07, 1968 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Orson Bean, Arlene Francis | Jack Cassidy, #3 Shirley Jones |
| 20 | 11/13/68 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Godfrey Cambridge, AF | Denny McLain, Marty Allen |
| 21 | 11/19/68 | SS, Phyllis Newman, Gawn Granger, AF | Tammy Grimes, James Brown |
| 22 | 11/26/68 | ... | Sally Ann Howes, Claire Bloom, Vikki Carr |
| 23 | 12/03/68 | Jack Cassidy | Skitch Henderson, Helen Gurley Brown, Jackie Mason |
| 24 | 12/10/68 | SS, Meredith MacRae, Joel Grey, AF | Dustin Hoffman, Dick Shawn, Earl Wilson, Susannah York |
| 25 | 12/17/68 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Garry Moore, AF | Shari Lewis, Dizzy Gillespie |
| 26 | 12/24/68 | ... | Milt Kamen, Aliza Kashi, Diana Sands |
| 27 | 12/31/68 | SS, Peggy Cass, Bert Convy, AF | Lesley Gore, Joey Adams, Alan Alda |
| 28 | 01/07/69 | ... | Prof. Irwin Corey, Phil Ford, Mimi Hines, Robert Merrill, Nina Simone |
| 29 | 01/14/69 | Gene Rayburn, Dr. Joyce Brothers, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | John Davidson, Anita Gillette, Pigmeat Markham, Herschel Bernardi |
| 30 | 01/21/69 | ... | Ed Begley, Durward Kirby, Frank Sinatra Jr., Maureen Stapleton |
| 31 | 01/28/69 | SS, Ruta Lee, Alan Alda, AF | Phil Foster, Vivian Vance, Bud Collyer, Zsa Zsa Gabor |
| #032 (#0311-#0315) | February 04, 1969 | Soupy Sales, Shari Lewis, Bert Convy, Arlene Francis | #3 James Earl Jones, Tina Louise, Richardo Montalban, Jerry Vale |
| 33 | 02/20/69 | Gloria DeHaven | Linda Kay Henning, Tom Courtenay, Mike Minor, Anna Moffo, Edward Mulhare |
| 34 | 02/25/69 | Gene Rayburn, Gail Sheldon, Bert Convy, AF | Natalie Bruner, Anissa Jones, Leonard Lyons, Estelle Parsons |
| 35 | 03/04/69 | SS, Anita Gillette, Tony Roberts, AF | Myron Cohen, Julie Harris, Hal Holbrook, Arte Johnson, Alejandro Rey |
| 36 | 03/06/69 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Hal Holbrook, AF | Werner Klemperer, Vidal Sassoon, Gretchen Wyler, John Gary |
| 36 | 03/11/69 | SS, Phyllis Newman, Bert Convy, AF | Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara (Bozo the Clown), George Carlin, Barbara Walters |
| 38 | 03/18/69 | SS, Anita Gillette, John Gary, AF | Jim Brown, Bob Keeshan, Carmel Quinn, Jimmy Rodgers, Terry Thomas |
| 39 | 03/25/69 | SS, Gail Sheldon, Nipsey Russell, AF | Bert Convy, #3 Peter Nero, Craig Stevens, Monique Van Vooren |
Season 2 (1969–1970)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | 07/01/69 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Jack Cassidy, AF | Bob Crane, Fannie Flagg, George Kirby, Helen O'Connell, Jerry Orbach |
| 41 | 07/08/69 | Henry Morgan, Anita Gillette, Bert Convy, AF | Dody Goodman, Gloria DeHaven |
| 42 | 07/15/69 | Alan Alda, Gail Sheldon, Tony Roberts, AF | Eamonn Andrews, Milbourne Christopher, Julia Meade, Bert Parks, Slappy White |
| 43 | 07/24/69 | Gene Rayburn, Nancy Dussault, Alan Alda, AF | Rodney Dangerfield, Theodore Bikel, Cleon Jones |
| 44 | 07/31/69 | Gene Rayburn, Jayne Meadows, Phyllis Newman, Bennett Cerf | Don Meredith, Alec McCowen, Carlos Montoya, Buddy Rich, Jerome Weidman |
| 45 | 08/07/69 | Gene Rayburn, Meredith MacRae, Henry Morgan, AF | Heather MacRae, Corbett Monica, Patrick O'Neal |
| 46 | 08/14/69 | Gene Rayburn, Peggy Cass, Joanne Carson, Bennett Cerf | Pat Hingle, Arthur Ashe, Billy Daniels, Jerry Lester |
| #047 (#0461-#0465) | August 21, 1969 | Gene Rayburn, Nancy Dussault, Jack Cassidy, Sue Oakland | Joe Frazier, Moms Mabley, Jan Sterling |
| #048 (#0471-#0475) | August 28, 1969 | Gene Rayburn, Brenda Vaccaro, Joanna Barnes, Bennett Cerf | Gerald R. Ford, #2 Don DeFore, Hazel Scott, Roy Campanella |
| 49 | 09/11/69 | SS, Gail Sheldon, Jack Cassidy, AF | Carmen Cavallaro, Robert Hooks, Troy Donahue |
| #050 (#0491-#0495) | September 18, 1969 | Soupy Sales, Betty White, Alejandro Rey, Arlene Francis | Kaye Ballard, Robert Culp, Chester Morris, #4 Jaye P. Morgan, #5 Claire Trevor |
| #051 (#0501-#0505) | September 25, 1969 | Henry Morgan, Emily Yancy, Bert Convy, Arlene Francis | Stanley Kramer, Mrs. Miller, Kyle Rote, Ozzie Nelson, #4 Harriet Nelson |
| 52 | 10/02/69 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Bennett Cerf, AF | Tessie O'Shea, Emilio Pucci, Tiny Tim |
| 53 | 10/09/69 | Gene Rayburn, Jaye P. Morgan, Bert Convy, AF | Jerry Grote, Barry Morse, Barry Nelson, Doc Severinsen, Clint Eastwood |
| 54 | 10/16/69 | SS, Dina Merrill, Mark Russell, AF | Rosey Grier, Hugh Downs, Roger Smith |
| 55 | 10/20/69 | ... | Frank Gorshin |
| 56 | 10/23/69 | SS, Emily Yancy, Patrick O'Neill, AF | Pat Carroll, Rita Moreno, Jack Valenti, Senor Wences, Toots Shor |
| 57 | 10/30/69 | SS, Gail Sheldon, ?, AF | Kier Dullea, Rona Jaffe, Joshua Logan, Sam Levene |
| #058 (#0561-#0565) | November 06, 1969 | ... | #2 Florence Henderson, Vincent Sardi, Julie Wilson |
| 59 | 11/13/69 | ... | Ray Goulding, James Drury, Bob Elliot, Erroll Garner |
| 60 | 11/20/69 | ... | Dick Clark, Nancy Ames, Jim Backus, John McGiver |
| #061 (#0591-#0595) | November 26, 1969 | Soupy Sales, Phyllis Newman, Mark Russell, Arlene Francis | Lester Lianin, #3 June Lockhart, Robbi Morgan |
| 62 | 12/04/69 | SS, Nancy Dussault, Alan Alda, AF | Lillian Gish, Butterfly McQueen, Marguerite Piazza |
| 63 | 12/11/69 | ... | Jimmy Breslin, Cleveland Amory, Kathy Garver |
| 64 | 12/18/69 | ... | Ann Corio, Molly Picon |
| 65 | 12/24/69 | ... | London Lee, Oliver, Mrs. Alejandro Rey, Walter Slezak, Enzo Stuarti |
| 66 | 12/31/69 | SS, Meredith McRae, Gene Rayburn, AF | Wally Bruner, Peter Gabel, Robert Horton, Sol Hurok, Greg Mullavey |
| 67 | 01/08/70 | ... | Joanna Barnes, Linda Cristal, Budd Schulberg, Oscar de la Renta |
| 68 | 01/15/70 | ... | Brian Bedford, Joanne Carson, Broderick Crawford |
| 69 | 01/22/70 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Jack Cassidy, AF | Noel Harrison, Kevin McCarthy, Roberta Peters, Norman Rockwell, Jules Styne |
| 70 | 01/29/70 | Noel Harrison | Charles Aznavour, Norm Crosby, Buddy Greco, Morty Gunty, Gene Krupa |
| 71 | 02/05/70 | ... | Patty Duke, Karl Malden, John Saxon, Forrest Tucker |
| 72 | 02/12/70 | SS, Linda Cristal, Allen Ludden, Anita Gillette | Corrine Calvet, David Frost, Mervyn LeRoy, Jane Withers, Betty White |
| 73 | 02/19/70 | ... | Sandy Baron, Eddy Arnold, James Farentino, Patachou, Robert Lansing |
| 74 | 02/27/70 | ... | Ross Hunter, Jed Allen, Sylvia Miles, Stella Stevens |
| #075 (#0731-#0735) | March 05, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Gail Sheldon, Alejandro Rey, Arlene Francis | Horace McMahon, #3 Jack Carter (also, Wilma Rudolph), Jan Peerce, Rip Torn |
| 76 | 03/12/70 | Sandy Baron | Hans Conried, Janet Blair, Buster Crabbe, Jonathan Frid |
| #077 (#0751-#0755) | March 19, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Jim Backus, Arlene Francis | Rich Little, #1 Lily Tomlin (also, Hubert de Givenchy) |
| 78 | 03/26/70 | Morty Gunty | Reiko and Jack Douglas, Sammy Kaye, Roddy McDowall, Claudia McNeil, Nicol Williamson |
Season 3 (1970–1971)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 79 | 04/09/70 | Soupy Sales, Gail Sheldon, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | Bill Dana, Blythe Danner, Jack Narz, Marcel Marceau |
| #080 (#0791-#0795) | April 16, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Werner Klemperer, Arlene Francis | The Mills Brothers, Jane Kean, #3 Shelley Winters (also, Clayton Moore), Mason Williams |
| 81 | 04/20/70 | ... | Geraldine Brooks, Judy Carne, Jo Ann Pflug, Selma Diamond, Arch Buchwald |
| #082 (#0801-#0805) | April 23, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Joanna Barnes, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | Helen Rayburn, Brian Aherne, Stanley Myron Handelman, Denise Nicholas, #5 Burgess Meredith |
| 83 | 04/30/70 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Robert Q. Lewis, Arlene Francis | #1 Juliet Mills, Tony Randall, Mitch Miller, Prof. Irwin Corey, Tony Randall |
| 84 | 05/07/70 | SS, Sandy Duncan, Alan Alda, AF | Elaine Stritch |
| #085 (#0831-#0835) | May 14, 1970 | Gene Rayburn, Gail Sheldon, Bert Convy, Arlene Francis | Jacqueline Bisset, #3 Frankie Avalon, Suzanne Pleshette, Kay Stevens |
| 86 | 05/18/70 | SS, Sandy Duncan, Bennett Cerf, AF | Louis Nye, Peggy Fleming |
| 87 | 06/04/70 | SS, Tammy Grimes, Allen Ludden, AF | B. B. King |
| 88 | 06/11/70 | SS, Sally Ann Howes, Bert Convy, AF | Richard Tucker, Walt Frazier |
| 89 | 06/18/70 | SS, Sandy Duncan, Henry Morgan, AF | Melba Moore, Michael Constantine |
| 90 | 06/25/70 | Soupy Sales, Gail Sheldon, Alejandro Rey, Arlene Francis | Gil Fates, Charles Nelson Reilly, #5 Barbara Walters (450th Episode) |
| 91 | 08/20/70 | SS, Anita Gillette, Gene Rayburn, AF | Barbara Barrie, Rodney Dangerfield |
| #092 (#0921-#0925) | August 27, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Gawn Grainger, Arlene Francis | Cass Elliot, #2 Billie Jean King, Celeste Holm, Earl Wilson |
| 93 | 09/03/70 | SS, Gail Sheldon, Gawn Grainger, AF | Ed Nelson, Rita Gam, Buffy Sainte-Marie |
| #094 (#0941-#0945) | September 10, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | #4 Larry Kert, Skitch Henderson, Lionel Hampton |
| 95 | 09/17/70 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Larry Blyden, AF | Ruby Dee, Jacqueline Susann, Cyril Ritchard |
| 96 | 10/05/70 | SS, Anita Gillette, Bennett Cerf, AF | Alan Sues, Peter Falk, Kitty Carlisle, Ed McMahon |
| 97 | 10/08/70 | SS, Anita Gillette, Robert Morse, AF | Jake LaMotta, Ann-Margret, John Raitt, Helen Gurley Brown |
| 98 | (10/12/70) | SS, Sheila MacRae, Alejandro Rey, AF | Edie Adams, #2 Peggy Cass, John Forsythe |
| 99 | 10/15/70 | SS, Sandy Duncan, Alan Alda, AF | Johnny Mercer, James Coco, Patricia Medina, Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Cotten, Betsy Palmer |
| 100 | 10/22/70 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Bert Convy, AF | Jim Bouton, Dore Schary, 500th Episode Larry Blyden |
| #101 (#1021-#1025) | November 05, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Phyllis Newman, Bennett Cerf, Arlene Francis | #5 Mel Brooks, The Duke of Bedford, Roger Williams |
| 102 | 11/19/70 | Melba Toliver, Barbara Howar | Anthony Quayle, Nancy Wilson, Howard Duff |
| 103 | 11/25/70 | Lady Antonia Wardell | Ron Johnson, Chill Wills |
| #104 (#1061-#1065) | December 03, 1970 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Robert Morse, Arlene Francis | Elizabeth Allen, Jackie Kannon, #4 Carl Stokes |
| 105 | 12/10/70 | ... | Betty Furness, George Plimpton, Sandler & Young |
| 106 | 12/17/70 | Carole Shelley | Betsy Von Furstenberg |
| 107 | 12/24/70 | ... | David Burns, Sandy Duncan, Jenny O'Hara, Alice Playten |
| 108 | 12/31/70 | John Schubeck | Howard Cosell, Mildred Dunnock, Mickey Spillane |
| 109 | 01/07/71 | ... | Diana Lynn, Lana Cantrell |
| 110 | 01/14/71 | ... | Dom DeLuise |
| 111 | 01/21/71 | ... | Della Reese, Busby Berkeley |
| 112 | 01/28/71 | ... | Henry Mancini, Rachel Roberts, David Steinberg, Nancy Dickerson |
| 113 | 02/04/71 | SS, Anita Gillette, Jack Cassidy, AF | Patsy Kelly, William Shatner, Melvin Belli |
| 114 | 02/11/71 | SS, Sandy Duncan, Henry Morgan, AF | Chuck McCann, Satchel Paige |
| 115 | 02/18/71 | Kay Ballard | Gail Fisher, Rod Laver, Dana Andrews |
| 116 | 02/25/71 | ... | Lainie Kazan, John Marley |
| #117 (#1011-#1015) | March 04, 1971 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Bennett Cerf, Arlene Francis | Lassie, Jack Gilford, #3 Burt Reynolds, Louis Prima |
Season 4 (1971–1972)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 118 | 04/08/71 | ... | Irving Caesar, Beverly Sills |
| 119 | 04/15/71 | ... | Chita Rivera |
| 120 | 04/22/71 | ... | Helen Gallagher, Harve Presnell |
| 121 | 05/06/71 | June Lockhart | Geraldine Fitzgerald |
| 122 | 05/13/71 | SS, Meredith MacRae, Gene Rayburn, AF | Barbara Anderson, Robert Clary |
| 123 | 05/20/71 | ... | Dorothy Collins, Charley Manner, Eileen Farrell |
| 124 | 05/27/71 | ... | George Shearing |
| 125 | 06/03/71 | ... | Yvonne DeCarlo |
| 126 | 06/10/71 | ... | David Hemmings |
| 127 | 06/17/71 | Helen O'Connell | Kim Hunter, Carolyn Jones |
| 128 | 06/24/71 | Sue Lyon | Marty Ingels, Sue Ane Langdon |
| 129 | 07/01/71 | ... | Dana Valery |
| 130 | 07/09/71 | Dana Valery | Nina Foch |
| 131 | 07/12/71 | ... | Billy DeWolfe |
| 132 | 07/15/71 | ... | Ralph Meeker, Constance Towers |
| #133 (#1341-#1345) | July 22, 1971 | Gail Sheldon, Eamonn Andrews, Sally Ann Howes, Soupy Sales | Charo, Roger Moore, #4 Odetta |
| 134 | 07/29/71 | SS, Dana Valery, Jack Cassidy, AF | Bob Smith, Edward Arnold, Claudia Cardinale, Oliver Reed |
| 135 | 08/05/71 | SS, Natalie Bruner, Bennett Cerf, AF | Fannie Flagg |
| 136 | 08/12/71 | ... | James Darren, Eileen Fulton, Bobby Mercer |
| 137 | 08/19/71 | ... | Anne Baxter, Hume Cronyn |
| 138 | 08/21/71 | Gene Shalit | ... |
| 139 | 08/26/71 | SS, Anita Gillette, Jim Backus, AF | Margaret Court Smith, Rich Little |
| 140 | 09/02/71 | ... | Ilka Chase, Hal Linden, Woody Strode |
| 141 | 09/09/71 | ... | Ruby Keeler, Bernadette Peters |
| 142 | 09/16/71 | ... | Bobby Short |
| 143 | 09/23/71 | Soupy Sales, June Lockhart, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | Keith Baxter, Evelyn Keyes, Frank Zappa |
| 144 | 09/30/71 | ... | Hildegard Knef, Edward Villella |
| 145 | 10/07/71 | Florence Henderson | ... |
| #146 (#1461-#1465) | October 14, 1971 | Gene Rayburn, Anita Gillette, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | John Gavin, #2 Jo Anne Worley |
| 147 | 10/21/71 | Gene Rayburn, Dana Valery, Orson Bean, Arlene Francis | Jose Greco, Gene Shalit, Gene Hackman |
| 148 | 10/28/71 | ... | Peter Viertel |
| 149 | 11/04/71 | ... | Lou Jacobi, Richard Kiley |
| 150 | 11/11/71 | ... | Jose Feliciano, Richard Harris |
| 151 | 11/18/71 | SS, Phyllis Newman, Peter Marshall, AF | Jimmy Roselli, Lowell Thomas, Joe Frazier |
| 152 | 11/24/71 | Soupy Sales, Melba Tolliver, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | Monty Hall, Tommy Leonetti, Harriet Van Horne |
| 153 | 12/02/71 | ... | Geoffrey Holder, Harold Robbins, Brenda Vaccaro, Charlie Callas |
| 154 | 12/09/71 | ... | Donald Pleasance, Robert Shaw, Sam Spiegel |
| 155 | 12/16/71 | ... | Vittorio di Sica, Marcia Rodd |
| #156 (#1561-#1565) | December 23, 1971 | Gene Rayburn, Melba Tolliver, Alan Alda, Arlene Francis | #4 Louis Gossett Jr., James MacArthur, Rose Marie |
Season 5 (1972–1973)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| #157 (#1571-#1575) | July 20, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Dana Valery, Gene Shalit, Melba Tolliver | #1 Peter Lind Hayes, #2 Maureen Stapleton, #3 Sheila MacRae, #4 Count Basie, #5 Artie Shaw |
| #158 (#1581-#1585) | July 27, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | #1 Helen Gurley Brown, #2 Joan Fontaine, #3 Buddy Rich, #4 Tom Poston *Last one Unknown* |
| #159 (#1591-#1595) | August 03, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | #1 Joe Garagiola, #2 Hermione Gingold, #3 Jack E. Leonard, #4 Henry Gibson, #5 Roberta Peters |
| #160 (#1601-#1605) | August 10, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Gail Sheldon, Allen Ludden, Arelen Francis | #1 Allen Funt, #2 Gene Shalit, #3 Jerry Vale, #4 Art Carney, #5 Allan Sherman |
| #161 (#1611-#1615) | August 17, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | #1 Dina Merrill, #2 Rocky Graziano, #3 Tiny Tim, #4 Patsy Kelly, #5 Duke Ellington |
| #162 (#1621-#1625) | August 24, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Melba Tolliver, Jim Backus, Arlene Francis | #1 Guy Lombardo, #2 Jim Brown, #3 Henny Youngman, #4 Dick Shawn, #5 Robert Culp |
| #163 (#1631-#1635) | August 31, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Dana Valery, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | #1 Cyril Ritchard, #2 Ken Rosewall, #3 Joel Grey, #4 Earl Wilson, #5 David Wayne |
| #164 (#1641-#1645) | September 07, 1972 | Gene Rayburn, Sheila MacRae, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | #1 Peggy Cass, #2 Dave Brubeck, #3 Patrick MacNee, #4 Peter Duchin, #5 Mel Torme |
| #165 (#1651-#1655) | September 14, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Mel Torme, Arlene Francis | #1 Burl Ives, #2 Aliza Kashi, #3 Ginger Rogers, #4 Darren McGavin, #5 Melba Moore |
| #166 (#1661-#1665) | September 21, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Joanna Barnes, Tony Roberts, Arlene Francis | #1 Terry Ann Meeuwsen (Miss America 1973), #2 Arlene Dahl, #3 Helen Hayes, #4 Robert Morse, #5 Jesse Owens |
| #167 (#1671-#1675) | September 28, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Aliza Kashi, Alan Alda, Arlene Francis | #1 Professor Irwin Corey, #2 Lisa Kirk, #3 Howard Cosell, #4 Skitch Henderson, #5 Joey Adams |
| #168 (#1681-#1685) | October 05, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Dana Valery, Alan Alda, Arlene Francis | *First two unknown* #3 Phyllis Newman, #4 Garry Moore, Rona Barrett |
| #169 (#1691-#1695) | October 12, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Melba Tolliver, Allen Ludden, Arlene Francis | #1 Celeste Holm, #2 Marty Ingels, #3 Joan Bennett, #4 Jack Cassidy, #5 Jerry Orbach |
| #170 (#1701-#1705) | October 19, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Sherrye Henry, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | #1 Lotte Lenya, #2 Rex Reed, #3 Frank Gifford, #4 Patty Duke, #5 Trini Lopez |
| #171 (#1711-#1715) | October 26, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Gail Sheldon, Alan Alda, Joanna Barnes | #1 Bob Elliott & Ray Goulding, #2 Charles Aznavour, #3 Betsy Palmer, #4 Rodney Dangerfield, #5 Ethel Merman |
| #172 (#1721-#1725) | November 02, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Ruta Lee, Alan Alda, Arlene Francis | #1 Ruby Dee, #2 Captain Kangaroo (Bob Keeshan), #3 Andre Kostelanetz, #4 Kerry Wells (Miss Universe), #5 Dorothy Lamour |
| #173 (#1731-#1735) | November 09, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Sherrye Henry, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | #1 Orson Bean, #2 Stubby Kaye, #3 Jessica Tandy & Hume Cronyn, #4 Geoffrey Holder, #5 Pat Cooper |
| #174 (#1741-#1745) | November 16, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Dana Valery, Allen Ludden, Arlene Francis | #1 Jo Anne Worley, #2 George Maharis, #3 Yogi Berra, #4 Olivia de Havilland, #5 Robert Shaw |
| #175 (#1751-#1755) | November 23, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | #1 Sandy Baron, #2 Lucie Arnaz, #3 Jean Pierre Aumont & Marisa Pavan, #4 Betty White, #5 Dizzy Gillespie |
| #176 (#1761-#1765) | November 30, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Sherrye Henry, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | #1 Jerry Stiller & Anne Meara, #2 Minnesota Fats, #3 Woody Herman, #4 Martha Raye, #5 Shelley Winters |
| #177 (#1771-#1775) | December 07, 1972 | Gene Rayburn, Phyllis George, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | Richard Deacon, #2 Glynis Johns, #3 Cleveland Amory, #4 James Coco, Lana Cantrell |
| #178 (#1781-#1785) | December 14, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Sherrye Henry, Jack Cassidy, Arlene Francis | #1 George Kirby, #2 Larry Storch, #3 Mickey Spillane, #4 Willie Mays, #5 Susannah York |
| #179 (#1791-#1795) | December 21, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Dana Valery, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | #1 Walter Slezak, #2 Otto Preminger, #3 Werner Klemperer, #4 Marty Allen, #5 Bernadette Peters |
| #180 (#1801-#1805) | December 28, 1972 | Soupy Sales, Joanna Barnes, Werner Klemperer, Arlene Francis | #1 Julie Budd, #2 The Amazing Kreskin, #3 Julie Harris, #4 B.B. King, #5 Sam Levene |
| #181 (#1811-#1815) | January 04, 1973 | Henry Morgan, Phyllis George, Tony Roberts, Arlene Francis | #1 Lonra Luft, #2 Dane Clark, #3 Fran Allison, #4 Elaine Joyce, #5 Julius LaRosa |
| #182 (#1821-#1285) | January 11, 1973 | Gene Rayburn, Melba Tolliver, Mark Goodson, Arlene Francis | Julie Newmar, #2 Myron Cohen, Hazel Scott, Don Stewart, #5 Bill Todman |
| #183 (#1831-#1835) | January 18, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Sherrye Henry, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | #1 Douglas Fairbanks Jr., #2 Cicely Tyson, #3 Jack Albertson, #4 Stevie Wonder, #5 Ricardo Montalban |
| #184 (#1841-#1845) | January 25, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Joanna Simon, Allen Ludden, Arlene Francis | #1 Robert Merrill (One model is future motion picture actress Angelica Huston), #2 Kay Medford, #3 Robert Clary, #4 Edward Mulhare, #5 Freda Payne |
| #185 (#1851-#1855) | February 01, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | #1 Sid Caesar, #2 Art Fleming, June Lockhart, Morty Gunty, Donna Jean Young |
| #186 (#1861-#1865) | February 08, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Lucie Arnaz, Gene Rayburn, Arlene Francis | Agnes Moorehead, Jim Bailey, #2 Richard Chamberlain, Eddie Albert, Cab Calloway |
| 187 | 02/15/73 | SS, Anita Gillette, Leonard Harris, AF | Eve Arden, Robert Lansing (Guests include Popcorn King Orville Redenbacker), David Birney, Norm Crosby, Kaye Ballard |
| 188 | 02/22/73 | SS, Melba Tolliver, Gene Shalit, AF | Chuck Connors, Paul Lynde, Patricia Neal, Peter Marshall, Lainie Kazan |
| 189 | 03/01/73 | SS, Sherrye Henry, Alejandro Rey, AF | Rip Torn, Maureen O'Sullivan, (Guest: Baroness Maria Von Trapp whose life inspired the play and movie "The Sound of Music"), Robert Klein, Jacqueline Bisset |
| #190 (#1901-#1905) | March 08, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Phyllis George, Leonard Harris, Arlene Francis | Jimmy the Greek also Shari Lewis, #2 Frankie Laine, Wilfrid Hyde-White, Ted Knight, Michael York |
| 191 | (3/15/73) | SS, Elaine Joyce (2)/Marcia Rodd (3), Allen Ludden, AF | Helen O'Connell, Bobby Van, Zsa Zsa Gabor, Bert Convy, Noel Harrison |
| 192 | (3/22/73) | SS, Meredith MacRae, Bert Convy, AF | Anita Gillette, Ozzie and Harriet Nelson, Jayne Meadows, Louis Nye, Steve Allen |
| 193 | 03/29/73 | Anita Gillette, Alan Alda, Sherrye Henry, SS | Nanette Fabray, Adrienne Barbeau, Michele Lee, Jacqueline Susann, Barbara Feldon |
| 194 | (4/5/73) | SS, Joanna Barnes, Leonard Harris, AF | Alejandro Rey (William Gaines and Dick DeBartolo of MAD Magazine), Anna Moffo, Mark Goodson, Nipsey Russell, Don Murray |
Season 6 (1973–1974)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 195 | 05/10/73 | SS, Melba Tolliver, Alan Alda, AF | Dr. Joyce Brothers, Benny Goodman, Myrna Loy, Baroness Nina Van Pallandt, E.G. Marshall |
| 196 | (5/17/73) | SS, Marcia Rodd, Leonard Harris, AF | Monique Van Vooren, Ed McMahon, Patrick O'Neal, Edward Albert, Pat Cooper |
| 197 | 05/24/73 | Gene Rayburn, Sherrye Henry, Alan Alda, AF | Kim Hunter, Peter Nero, Ernest Borgnine, Larry Storch, Phyllis Diller |
| 198 | 05/31/73 | SS, Dana Valery, Gene Shalit, AF | Vida Blue, David McCallum, Rhonda Fleming, Chubby Checker, Brenda Lee |
| 199 | 06/07/73 | SS, Meredith MacRae, Alan Alda, AF | James Brolin, Sheila MacRae, Buddy Greco, Connie Francis |
| 200 | 06/14/73 | SS, Anna Moffo, Alan Alda, AF | Calvin Klein also Kitty Carlisle, Gwen Verdon, Pat Carroll, Charles Nelson Reilly, Ben Vereen |
| #201 (#2011-#2015) | June 21, 1973 | Jack Cassidy, Anita Gillette, Bert Convy, Arlene Francis | #1 Wally Bruner, Binnie Barnes, Loretta Swit, George Plimpton, Lucie Arnaz |
| 202 | 06/28/73 | SS, Dana Valery, Greg Morris, AF | Stanley Kramer, Robert Shaw, Leonard Nimoy, Polly Bergen, Lionel Hampton |
| 203 | 07/05/73 | Henry Morgan, Sherrye Henry, Jack Cassidy, AF | Pat Hingle, John Gavin, Glynis Johns, Big Bird, Professor Irwin Corey |
| 204 | 07/12/73 | Gene Rayburn, Anita Gillette, Leonard Harris, AF | Bob and Ray, Eubie Blake, Jaye P. Morgan, Peggy Cass, Janis Paige |
| 205 | 07/19/73 | SS, Anita Gillette, Bert Convy, AF | Joe Garagiola, Meredith MacRae, McLean Stevenson, Patsy Kelly, Dick Clark |
| 206 | (7/26/73) | SS, Marcia Rodd, Allen Ludden, AF | Darren McGavin, Gig Young, Patrick MacNee, Woody Herman, Lois Nettleton |
| 207 | 08/02/73 | SS, Sherrye Henry, Gene Shalit, AF | Skitch Henderson, Alice Playten, Phil Foster, Kevin McCarthy, Billy Taylor |
| 208 | 08/09/73 | SS, Ruta Lee, Leonard Harris, AF | Jim Bouton, Alan Sues, Hugh O'Brian, Ossie Davis, Johnny Nash |
| 209 | (8/16/73) | Gene Rayburn, Dana Valery, Tony Roberts, AF | Gene Shalit, Jack Palance, Hermione Gingold, Sam Levenson, Hazel Scott |
| 210 | (8/23/73) | SS, Dr. Joyce Brothers, Gene Shalit, AF | Jerry Orbach, Teresa Brewer, Arlene Dahl, Helen O'Connell, Rachel Roberts |
| 211 | 08/30/73 | SS, Melba Tolliver, Leonard Harris, AF | Earl Wilson, Sen. William Proxmire, Marion McPartland, Gretchen Wyler |
| 212 | 09/06/73 | SS, Marcia Rodd, Werner Klemperer, AF | Gordie Howe & Sons, Shelley Berman, Nancy Walker, Gloria Swanson, Mimi Hines |
| #213 (#2131-#2135) | September 13, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Mel Torme, Arlene Francis | Robert Vaughn, Robin Moore, Rebecca Ann King (Miss America '74), #4 Gordon MacRae, Dick Shawn |
| 214 | 09/20/73 | SS, Carole Shelley, Gene Shalit, AF | Godfrey Cambridge, Judy Carne, Jose Ferrer, Eddie Egan, George Montgomery |
| 215 | 09/27/73 | SS, Dana Valery, Allen Ludden, AF | Marilyn Horne, Jacqueline Bisset, Geoffrey Holder, Lorna Luft |
| 216 | (10/4/73) | SS, Joanna Simon, Henry Morgan, AF | Robert Morse, Cab Calloway, Rosey Grier, Janet Lynn |
| 217 | (10/11/73) | SS, Melba Tolliver, Peter Lawford, AF | Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara, Estelle Parsons, Virginia Graham, Lillian Gish, Barry Nelson |
| 218 | (10/18/73) | SS, Marcia Rodd, Leonard Harris, AF | Jack Gilford, Ozzie and Harriet Nelson, Bess Myerson, Dizzy Gillespie, Jack Cassidy |
| #219 (#2191-#2195) | October 25, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Lois Nettleton (2)/Virginia Vestoff (3), Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | Peter Marshall, #2 The Modern Jazz Quartet, Barbara Walters, George Grizzard, Tammy Grimes |
| 220 | 11/01/73 | SS, Sherrye Henry, Charles Nelson Reilly, AF | Rita Moreno, Brock Peters, Robert Lansing, Cleveland Amory, Peter Cook & Dudley Moore |
| 221 | 11/08/73 | SS, Fannie Flagg, Allen Ludden, AF | Liv Ullmann, Bernadette Peters, Michael York, Morty Gunty |
| #222 (#2221-#2225) | November 15, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Skitch Henderson, Arlene Francis | Bibi Andersson, Harold Arlen, Jackie Vernon, Alfred Drake, #5 Agnes Moorehead |
| #223 (#2231-#2235) | November 21, 1973 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Jerry Orbach, Arlene Francis | #1 Eileen Heckart, Gladys Knight & the Pips, Helen Gurley Brown, Nipsey Russell, Garson Kanin |
| 224 | (11/29/73) | SS, Joanna Simon, Leonard Harris, AF | Abe Burrows, Alan Jay Lerner, Rocky Graziano, Peter Duchin, Carl Reiner |
| 225 | 12/06/73 | SS, Elaine Joyce, Gene Rayburn (4)/Allen Ludden (1), AF | Leo Durocher, Ricky Segall, Richard Deacon, Lana Cantrell, Bobby Riggs |
| 226 | 12/13/73 | SS, Dana Valery, Gene Shalit, AF | Joan Fontaine (future president Jimmy Carter), Allen Funt, Sandy Dennis, Gerry Mulligan, Jo Ann Pflug |
| 227 | 12/20/73 | SS, Dr. Joyce Brothers, Gene Rayburn, AF | Bobby Van and Elaine Joyce, Captain Kangaroo (Bob Keeshan), Cicely Tyson, Barbara McNair, Anita Gillette |
| 228 | 12/27/73 | [Larry Blyden has a broken foot during this taping day.] | Peter Gabel, Kurt Kasznar, Werner Klemperer, Sandy Baron, Eileen Fulton |
| 229 | 01/03/74 | SS, Rita Moreno, Henry Morgan, AF | Jackie "Moms" Mabley, Peter Maas, June Havoc, Melba Moore, George Hamilton |
| 230 | 01/10/74 | SS, Marcia Rodd, Werner Klemperer, AF | Stan Smith, Colleen Dewhurst |
| 231 | (1/17/74) | Gene Rayburn, Sherrye Henry, Gene Shalit, AF | Rip Torn, Henny Youngman, Phyllis Newman, Carol Channing |
| 232 | 01/25/74 | Soupy Sales, Elaine Joyce, Tony Roberts, Arlene Francis | Margaret Hamilton, Rodney Dangerfield, Hal Linden, Christopher Plummer, Walt Frazier |
Season 7 (1974–1975)[]
| Week #/Episode # | Taped | Panel | Mystery Guest(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 233 | 05/09/74 | SS, Anita Gillette, Gene Shalit, AF | Lynn Redgrave, Anne Baxter, Cyril Ritchard, The Amazing Kreskin, Enzo Stuarti |
| 234 | 05/16/74 | Gene Rayburn, Dana Valery, Henry Morgan, AF | Dana Andrews, Jane Powell, Esther Rolle, Sammy Cahn, Pat Carroll also Johnny Olson |
| 235 | 05/23/74 | SS, Joanna Barnes, Werner Klemperer, AF | Mark Goodson, Geraldine Fitzgerald, Buddy Rich, Emlyn Williams, Shelley Berman |
| 236 | 05/30/74 | SS, Anita Gillette, Skitch Henderson (2)/Buddy Rich (3), AF | Douglas Fairbanks Jr., Morty Gunty, Rodney Allen Rippy, Jean Pierre Aumont, Peter Marshall |
| 237 | 06/06/74 | SS, Lynn Redgrave, Allen Ludden, AF | Richard Deacon, Rosey Grier, Charles Nelson Reilly, George Rose, Hope Lange |
| 238 | 06/13/74 | SS, Marcia Rodd, Jim Bouton, AF | Dr. Joyce Brothers, Dave Brubeck, Myron Cohen, Sterling Moss, The Pointer Sisters |
| #239 (#2391-#2395) | June 20, 1974 | Soupy Sales, Lynn Redgrave, Gene Shalit, Arlene Francis | Betty Comden & Adolph Green, #2 Ruby Dee, Jackie Mason, Arlene Dahl, Dick Shawn |
| 240 | (6/27/74) | SS, Anita Gillette, Allen Ludden, AF | Anthony Perkins, Tippi Hedren, Eubie Blake, Professor Irwin Corey, Estelle Parsons |
| 241 | 07/03/74 | SS, Elaine Joyce, The Amazing Kreskin, AF | Morey Amsterdam, Dave Garroway, Don Murray, Marty Allen, Bobby Van |
| 242 | 07/11/74 | SS, Sherrye Henry, Gene Rayburn, Lynn Redgrave | Dave DeBusschere, Dina Merrill, Hans Conreid, Gene Shalit, Wayne Rogers |
| 243 | 07/18/74 | SS, Dana Valery, Jim Bouton, AF | Bobby Mercer, Alexis Smith, Werner Klemperer, Teddy Wilson, Maxine Andrews |
| 244 | (7/25/74) | Henry Morgan, Anita Gillette, Tony Roberts, AF | George Kirby, Sheila MacRae, Red Buttons, Anita Loos, Godfrey Cambridge |
| 245 | 07/30/74 | SS, Carole Shelley, Leonard Harris, AF | Rex Reed, Elizabeth Ashley, Joan Bennett, Art Carney, Mary Stuart |
| 246 | 08/01/74 | SS, Susan Oliver, Gene Rayburn, AF | Jo Ann Pflug, Earl Wilson, Jan Sterling, Marcia Rodd, Joe Williams |
| 247 | 08/08/74 | SS, Lynn Redgrave, Allen Ludden, AF | Fannie Flagg, Rodney Dangerfield, Jack Gilford, Vincent Gardenia, Lionel Hampton |
| 248 | 08/15/74 | SS, Dr. Joyce Brothers, Gene Rayburn, AF | Pat Cooper, Loretta Swit, Richard Dawson, Joan Blondell, Maureen Stapleton |
| 249 | 08/29/74 | SS, Elizabeth Ashley, Gene Rayburn, AF | Frank Gifford, Fred Gwynne, Keir Dullea, Betty Furness, Monique Van Vooren |
| 250 | 09/09/74 | SS, Dana Valery, Jerry Orbach, AF | Rita Moreno, Chet Gould, Ray Milland, Euell Gibbons also Kelly Garrett, Aretha Franklin |
| #251 (#2511-#2515) | September 12, 1974 | Soupy Sales, Meredith MacRae, Joe Silver, Arlene Francis | #4 Linda Blair, Peter Nero, Nipsey Russell, Alan Sues, Tammy Grimes |
| 252 | (9/19/74) | SS, Jayne Meadows, Steve Allen, AF | Phyllis Newman, Julie Newmar, Robert Merrill |
| 253 | 09/26/74 | SS, Rita Moreno, Jim Bouton, AF | Roger Moore, Garry Moore, Martin Gabel, Betsy Palmer, Frank Sinatra Jr. |
| 254 | 10/03/74 | SS, Lynn Redgrave, Allen Ludden, AF | Bobby Riggs, Pat Paulsen, Gwen Verdon, Frankie Laine, Tony Roberts |
| 255 | 10/10/74 | SS, Beverly Sills, Gene Shalit, AF | Schuyler Chapin, Steve Allen, Lainie Kazan, Anne Jackson |
| 256 | 10/17/74 | SS, Phyllis George, Gene Rayburn, AF | Barbara Feldon, Philippe Petit, Bert Parks, Charles Aznavour, Sandy Dennis |
| 257 | 10/20/74 | SS, Dana Valery, Alejandro Rey, AF | Jonathan Frid also Sheila Graham, Sergio Franchi, Rachel Roberts, Henny Youngman, Hermione Gingold |
| 258 | 10/27/74 | SS, Anita Gillette, Leonard Harris, AF | Brooks Robinson, Roberta Peters, Rocky Graziano |
| 259 | 10/31/74 | SS, Carole Shelley, Jim Bouton, AF | Kitty Carlisle, Tiny Tim, Jack Cassidy, Freda Payne, Lillian Roth |
| 260 | 11/07/74 | SS, Anita Gillette, The Amazing Kreskin, AF | Milton Berle, Henry Mancini, Anna Maria Alberghetti, Virginia Graham, Richard Kiley |
| 261 | 11/14/74 | SS, Dr.Joyce Brothers, Jack Cassidy, AF | Sally Kellerman, Frank Fontaine, Jim Henson (with Kermit the Frog) also Dick Cavett, Sammy Davis Jr., Olivia de Havilland |
| 262 | 11/21/74 | SS, Dana Valery, Bert Parks, AF | Jim Backus, Johnny Mathis, Helen O'Connell, Bernadette Peters, Leonard Nimoy |
| 263 | 12/05/74 | Gene Rayburn, Carole Shelley, Gene Shalit, AF | Peter Duchin, Peggy Cass, Peter Ustinov, Anna Moffo, Richard Chamberlain |
| #264 (#2641-#2645) | December 12, 1974 | Soupy Sales, Anita Gillette, Henry Morgan, Arlene Francis | Cab Calloway, Agnes DeMille, #3 Chita Rivera, Lorna Luft, #5 Shari Lewis |